When he finished the
chamber fell silent. Why? Because none of Brown’s
colleagues was present. He was addressing 99 empty chairs.
Sparse attendance in Congress is an historical fact, but this scene was depressing
nonetheless. The situation has gradually worsened as television and the Internet
make it easier for members to stay in touch without actually setting foot in
the chambers.
On the House side, Budget Committee chairman, Paul Ryan, R-Wis., was engaged
in his favorite pursuit: slashing. “We’re eliminating government
slush funds to stop bailouts,” he said of the GOP plan, “we’re
controlling runaway, unchecked spending.”
It was hard to tell if the few dozen House members in attendance were listening
to Ryan because most were busy with their own favorite pursuits: tapping away
on iPads and smartphones.
One of the first things Rep. John Boehner, R-Ohio, did after becoming Speaker
was revise House policy to permit mobile devices on the floor. The new rule allows
electronics unless their use “impairs decorum,” but policymakers
stopped short of adding a requirement for House members to actually pay attention.
The day I was there a glitch in the system blocked Apple products – iPhones
and iPads – connected to the official House network from receiving emails.
This caused quite a fuss, with the newspaper Roll Call quoting a Democratic spokesman
as saying, “Members of Congress have become more and more reliant on mobile
technology for floor proceedings.”
Is that a good thing? Congress has an approval rating of about 10 percent,
so you’d think avoiding distractions and showing up more often would be
good first steps in improving public perception if not the actual legislative
box score.
But the public doesn’t get a clear picture of this on television. C-SPAN,
the non-profit cable service providing coverage from the Hill, uses video feeds
supplied by House and Senate TV departments – and they avoid showing vast
expanses of empty seats or members distracted by handheld gadgets.
House rules require head-on coverage of members at the podium and forbid reaction
shots in the chamber. As a result, according to C-SPAN’s chief Brian Lamb,
the public gets “a less-than-complete view.” In a letter to Speaker
Boehner, Lamb called for a better “journalistic product” by allowing
additional robotic cameras that would be controlled by C-SPAN’s staff.
Boehner, like Democrat Nancy Pelosi before him, said no.
One exception comes during the annual State of the Union speech, when television
networks are allowed to determine the coverage. That yielded an infamous screenshot
a few years back of Rep. Eric Cantor, R-Va., fiddling with his Blackberry during
the president’s speech. Cantor said he was taking notes.
I came away from my visit feeling like I had just been in a college lecture
hall where the twin plagues are poor attendance by some, and relentless use of
mobile devices by others.
I contacted a C-SPAN executive for an update on efforts to improve coverage,
and was told that the service has recently added High Definition. So? “If
you look closely,” the gentleman said, “you can see which members
are using cell phones.”
As more voters get HD, approval ratings for Congress might disappear entirely.
(c) Peter Funt. This column was originally distributed by the Cagle Syndicate.
|